… while most reviews state the contrary.

I’m sorry. I’m a lover of alternative movies, weird movies, deep movies, confusing movies. But I deny to say I like a movie (or anything else) just because we’re supposed to love it. Within some groups, it seems unforgivable to say you don’t like some things. You have to pursue the label. You have to understand some things if you want to be considered an intellectual, for example. More than that, you have to say you love some things, even if you don’t. You have to say you’ve read certain books, even if you’re haven’t. This is why I’m apologizing, because this isn’t good for me – if it is for you, I’m sorry to disappoint you. Saying you like things you don’t is not a proof of intellectualism: it’s obviously a proof of dumbness.
I’ve just tried to watch L’Eclisse. I swear I insisted, and I swear I tried to find some details there that could be commented, and I even did. But it wasn’t natural. It was forced. In a normal situation, without trying to take some thing out of that, I would be completely frustrated. I do understand that we have to consider the decade when it was writtend and released, but this doesn’t make me think this movie is good. It’s a bad movie and you won’t have fun watching it, unless the movie helps you fall asleep and you have fun in your dreams. Worse still, it won’t give you creative insights to have deep thoughts and fruitful conversations afterwards, except if you want to criticize it, of course.
It’s a movie about the incommunicability, ok, but I bet I can find many other films that gives us better ideas on the subject. Scenes succeeding scenes make you wonder why those scenes are there, why they follow that order, what after all is the author trying to communicate. Ok, maybe nothing, but yet, just because of that, it wouldn’t make L’Eclisse a good movie. It’s just a famous movie that you’d better say you consider interesting if you want to be well accepted in academic, artistic and intellectual circles.
However, thinking that you should agree with me would be as dumb as saying you like the movie just because everybody else does. What I am advocating here is that we should have our own opinions, so go and watch it and see if it’s good for yourself. If it’s not, I just hope you’re bold enough to express it.